February 17, 2026

The practical benefits of moving from Cisco Umbrella to Cisco Secure Access

Milos Brkic
Solution Architect - Security

In our previous blog, we outlined what customers gain by moving to Cisco Secure Access, with a particular focus on what is genuinely new, what is materially improved and why those changes matter from a network and security operations perspective.

Why Secure Access exists in the first place

Cisco Secure Access represents the consolidation of several security capabilities that historically resided in separate products or control planes. This is the evolution of Umbrella into a modern security platform that aligns with secure service edge principles, where policy enforcement moves closer to the user and the application rather than relying on a fixed perimeter.

From a network perspective, this matters because traffic inspection, access decisions, and policy enforcement no longer depend on the user’s point of connection. Whether traffic originates on a corporate network, a home network, or a mobile connection, the same controls apply.

The key benefits customers can realise

Stronger protection without increasing complexity

Secure Access extends DNS-layer protection with deeper inspection and control, particularly for cloud applications and user access. Customers moving from Umbrella DNS to Secure Access DNS Defense gain additional malware protection, data loss prevention capabilities and AI-assisted threat detection without changing their traffic flow or architecture.

The important point is that this does not require enabling full proxy or zero-trust access on day one, as the transformation is a journey where the solution can evolve if/when your needs change and when the business is ready. DNS remains the enforcement point, but the intelligence behind it is broader and more tightly integrated with the rest of Cisco’s security stack.

A single policy model across users, networks, and applications

Simplified policy management has been a core improvement here. Secure Access introduces a more unified, rule-based policy model that applies consistently across DNS security, web traffic, application access and user identity.

Secure Access provides a single management interface across DNS Defense, Secure Internet Access, and Secure Private Access, whereas Umbrella splits capabilities and visibility between the DNS and SIG tiers. This reduces the operational gap between network teams, who think in terms of traffic flows, and security teams, who think in terms of identity and risk.

Built-in readiness for zero trust and private access

For customers not ready to adopt zero-trust network access today, Secure Access lowers the adoption barrier. The DNS Defense upgrade includes a trial of Secure Private Access for a limited number of users, allowing teams to test application access models without committing to a full rollout.

This is significant from a network design perspective. It allows organisations to gradually move away from VPN-centric access, validating performance and user experience before making architectural design changes.

What’s new in Secure Access compared to Umbrella

Secure Access introduces capabilities that either did not exist in Umbrella or were available only as limited add-ons:

  • Unified Secure Service Edge platform: Secure Access brings DNS security, secure web gateway, CASB, zero trust access, firewall-as-a-service, and private access into a single cloud-delivered platform. Umbrella delivered parts of this over time, but not as a unified control plane.
  • Expanded cloud application protection: Secure Access adds deeper inspection of cloud application traffic, including scanning uploads and updates for malware and enforcing data loss prevention policies across supported SaaS platforms. This capability is positioned as native rather than bolt-on.
  • AI-assisted threat detection: AI-driven DNS tunnelling detection and domain generation algorithm analysis help security teams identify more sophisticated threats earlier and reduce false positives.
  • Integrated secure private access: While Umbrella relied on traditional VPN or third-party ZTNA integrations, Secure Access embeds private application access directly into the platform, supporting both client-based and client-less access models, depending on the package tier.

What’s improved rather than entirely new

Some improvements are evolutionary rather than brand new, but still meaningful:

  • Policy creation and management: Secure Access simplifies the creation, ordering, and maintenance of policies. Compared with Umbrella, policy changes are faster to implement and easier to audit, especially in environments where DNS, web, and application controls overlap.
  • Migration flexibility: The Secure Access migration tooling allows Umbrella and Secure Access to run in parallel, enabling customers to migrate at their own pace. This dual-run model is designed to reduce risk and avoid forced cutovers.
  • Platform extensibility: Secure Access is now where Cisco is adding new security capabilities, including extended DLP, remote browser isolation, identity-based controls, and deeper integration with threat intelligence. Umbrella is largely feature-complete, but it won’t meet future cybersecurity needs. This can only be achieved through the ground-up platform re-architecture of Secure Access.

How this ties back to the network

From a Data#3 perspective, the most important benefit of Secure Access is not a feature checklist. It is the shift in which the network itself becomes the enforcement layer for security.

DNS, application access and traffic inspection all run on the same cloud-delivered fabric. This aligns network and security teams around a shared control plane rather than separate tools and policies. For existing Cisco networking customers, this provides a clearer path to a converged network and security architecture, without the need to layer new controls on legacy designs.

In practical terms, Secure Access allows organisations to modernise user security without redesigning their entire network overnight. DNS Defense becomes the entry point, with secure internet and private access added when the network and operational model are ready.

That staged approach is the real benefit. It reduces risk, preserves stability, and keeps the network central to the security strategy rather than treating it as an afterthought.

Data#3 can help you map your current Umbrella deployment to a realistic Secure Access pathway aligned with how your network operates. The first step is a simple migration discussion to assess where you are today and what the right next move looks like. Contact your account manager or submit the form below for more information.

Contact us

Cisco 360Partners Preferred Logo Security fc

Information provided within this form will be handled in accordance with our privacy statement.